Affiliate Marketing Mistakes – 2nd Place ML Winner

Congrats to our 2nd place winner, Richard.

The 6 Biggest Affiliate Marketing Mistakes I’ve Made – And What You Can Learn From Them

I have been affiliate marketing in one way or another for several years now, mainly using minisites in combination with search engine optimization (SEO) in order to drive traffic.

Because of that time I’ve probably made just about every affiliate marketing mistake possible but looking back there are 6 “biggies” that I’ve made that i think could have made a sizeable difference to how quickly I started to see results and the speed at which those results grew.

Since I started to fix these problems i have seen my results increase substantially so I’d encourage you to read on, honestly compare the mistakes I’ve made over the years with how *you* market affiliate programs online right now and as a result hopefully make a few changes to your strategies that will lead to a significant boost in results for you.

1) putting all my eggs into one basket

one site, one main affiliate offer, one search engine and one primary keyword worked for a while but when google changed it’s algorithm i sure felt like a chump as my income virtually dried up overnight. and that’s not an exaduration. putting all your eggs into one basket can lead to a very unstable business.

whether it’s getting hit with a google slap, dropped out of the search engines or having a merchant partner refuse to pay you for whatever reason if you haven’t got a backup plan then your affiliate marketing career cut be cut very short indeed.

even if you decide to specialise in one niche such as dating or credit cards, consider how you can diversify such as by using a few different affiliate offers, programs, websites and traffic strategies so that if one stops working you’re not going to lose your business overnight.

2) not testing different affiliate promotions

when the good times roll it’s too easy to see the commissions rolling in without trying any other offers. if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, right?

well, not quite in my experience.

i have had a couple of occasions where the checks kept coming and i put my feet up and took life easy for a while. then the sales started to dry up, or the promotion ended or they changed their terms and suddenly i was *forced* to find a new offer. next thing you know you find the new offer that you chucked online in next to no time is outpulling your old one by quite some margin and you have to wonder – how much more money *could* you have made if you weren’t quite so complacent?

the lesson here is clear – even if you have an offer that works, check with your affiliate manager on what else is converting well and split test them. sometimes you will pick the top converting offer in one niche and then weeks or months later a competing offer will come in that converts even better. or the same offer is runnig on another network, but with a better payout. except either your affiliate manager forgets to tell you, or you simply can’t be bothered to make changes to a campaign that’s already profitable.

be willing to put that extra effort in to tweak your marketing campaigns and achieve the very best results possible. it doesn’t just mean more potential profit for you – it also means if necessary you can afford to pay more for traffic and still stay in the black – which allows you to outcompete other, less careful affiliates.

3) getting the balance of analysis wrong

too many people, myself included when i first got started, suffer from “paralysis through analysis”. there is so much to think about, so much to learn and get right when you’re starting out that it can be hard to know where to start. so sometimes you don’t do anything at all. which obviously isn’t going to be earning you many commissions!

what seems to work better is just to jump in at the deep end. throw together a site. gather some links. buy some ads. and then analyse the results, and use these to improve.

most people do the analysis at the beginning and then next to none once they’ve launched a website or campaign. i’m suggesting far more the opposite. get started, then do your analysis to see which keywords are working, which offers are converting, what helped your search engine positioning, what was a waste of time and so on so over time you can develop your own “sixth sense” about what will work and what won’t.

you’ll also pick up business intelligence on things that work specifically for your niche that somebody new trying to enter it wouldn’t know. that’s valuable information and will help you keep ahead of the game.

another example of missing out due to lack of analysis *after* launching a site would be the one i built that was running smoothly on autopilot for months sucking in traffic from the search engines when i suddenly noticed i hadn’t made a sale in weeks when normally 2 days would have been unusual. it turned out that the merchant i was sending traffic to had changed their affiliate tracking software, and with it the url i was using to send them traffic so none of my conversions were being recorded.

luckily i had a good enough relationship with the merchant that they paid me a mutually-agreed sum to make up for it but it just goes to show how taking your eye off the ball can lead to frustration or even failure.

4) not knowing when to quit

we all know that quitting too soon can lead to failure but my problem has often been the opposite. i have been guilty of carrying on with a project working 12 hours a day to try and get something working long after i should have admitted defeat and tried something else.

some niches are just harder to make a go of than others. some buyers are particularly difficult to convert. some markets require pockets deeper than you may have to get a foothold. equally, you can fall into others where it seems so easy you can’t believe it. so make sure to give each marketing technique, each website, each affiliate offer a fair chance, but don’t be afraid to move on to greener pastures.

5) not scaling up a successful affiliate promotion

when i have found a niche that suddenly works well for me, i have been guilty of seeing the checks coming in and wanting to move onto the next thing rather than trying to scale up my results and become a major player in that field.

however, if you’re willing to take the time to do so, you can often negotiate higher commissions, recieve preferential treatment from your affiliate manager and find out about new promotions or conversion techniques that are working well before other smaller affiliates (if they find out at all!).

with the effort that you’ve put into finding the right keywords, ads, offers and so on aim to capitalize on that knowledge and try to wring every last cent out of a niche before moving on to your next victim!

6) neglecting the networking

there is a surprising amount of help available to you in the form of affiliate managers, informative blogs, forums, private mentoring and so on yet i have found it too easy in the past to focus 100% of my time on building pages, gathering links, testing offers and so on (the “mechanics”) that i’ve ignored the networking element.

paul has mentioned on several ocassions how much importance he puts on networking and how instrumental his blog has been in helping him succeed. it’s not just a matter of learning the ropes from others – though this can often help to cut short the learning curve by quite some time. it’s as much about learning what your target market is like. what keywords do they really use? what colors do they like? what “trust” factors can you add to your site to increase conversions? what sites do they hang out at that you could buy advertising on?

getting a deep understanding of your chosen niche from both ends – the leads you’re trying to attract – and the affiliate manager who is trying to help you convert them – you can attack the problem from both ends and really maximise the results you generate.

all the best,


  1. June 27, 2008

    what a sweet post and write up Richard – CONGRATULATIONS!!!!! Yea you got it! lol

  2. June 27, 2008

    Another great article! I can see why I didn’t win, I only wrote a paragraph lmao.

  3. June 27, 2008

    >1) putting all my eggs into one basket

    That is very good advise specially through organic search. We work with organic search a lot and we’ve had clients that we have put into the to 10 for keywords like home insurance, car insurance, mobile insurance, and many other super highly competitive terms, but then all suddenly their sites drop down about 5 pages because Google devalues their links. To be honest it’s just something they do and no one can do anything about it. I see sites getting smacked all the time even complete white hat sites that have acquired links naturally.

    It makes no sense what so ever, but that’s what they do if they see a site ranking very good on a ton of highly competitive terms and they don’t feel that the site deserved the rankings they’ll devalue some of their links if not penalize the site. Then again I have seen sites that are ranking on super competitive (a lot) and they have been ranking for years and never had any problems, but the main ideal is to build up as many sites as possible just encase that does happen.

  4. June 27, 2008

    tyler – your site is down

    Site Temporarily Unavailable
    We apologize for the inconvenience. Please contact the webmaster/ tech support immediately to have them rectify this.

    error id: “bad_httpd_conf”

  5. June 27, 2008

    I liked that you mentioned that knowing when to quit is very important. Too few people emphasis the importance of knowing when to move on.

  6. Ty
    June 27, 2008

    Great info here. This is the best bit:

    “there is so much to think about, so much to learn and get right when you’re starting out that it can be hard to know where to start. so sometimes you don’t do anything at all”

    Very well put and very true. Just do it.

  7. June 28, 2008



    Yea we’re in the process of transferring our registrars. We had a huge confrontation with dream host, so I close our account. Anyways it should be up by Monday for sure if not tomorrow.

  8. June 28, 2008

    Nice article Richard!

    I’d like to comment on the “Put all your eggs in one basket part”. Even though your offer got killed, you should always take away and remember that you made money on that area or particular niche. There is so much competition out there; offer wise and you know what keywords are converting. A keyword that’s converting on Google, will also convert on Yahoo! or MSN for that matter. So if you haven’t expanded your campaigns to other search engines (baskets) when your campaign was running smoothly: do it later.

    I love the quote: “If you don’t fail every once in a while, you’re not being very innovative”. So take away as much info as possible for each failure..

  9. June 28, 2008

    Wow, I actually won something :-)

    Thanks Paul. And thanks guys for all your comments so far. I’m on cloud nine right now!

  10. June 28, 2008

    hahahaha yea sure Rich but you didnt add your website, would give you more exposure you know?

  11. June 28, 2008

    awesome awesome post! I’m really glad that you’ve learned from your mistakes. I’m taking these into a lot of consideration as I am getting started :)

  12. Frank
    June 29, 2008

    Much better than the first story – far more information!

  13. June 29, 2008

    I like this story much more that previous too

  14. June 30, 2008

    Congrats to Winners

  15. June 30, 2008

    Congratulations Richard!

    I agree with 6) neglecting the networking:
    Publishers should utilize networking opportunities to learn more. Especially new Publishers coming in to the industry. Your Publisher manager is also there to help you. Reach out to them when you are unsure about something or have questions.


  16. July 1, 2008


    Yea we’re in the process of transferring our registrars

  17. July 3, 2008

    I agree with 2.) most!

  18. July 8, 2008

    Just wanted to say congrats. Great articles. Hope to hear more from you later.

    Shudogg Dot Com – Make Money Online Blogging

  19. April 8, 2009

    I haven’t read all the articles yet, but so far, you should’ve have got first place in my opinion. At least you gave concrete examples of your failures. Thank you for the great article!

Leave a Comment